Winning a direct shipper four miles from your yard feels like the hard part is over, but the deal you write before that first load decides whether the lane builds your business or slowly drains it, and nothing drains a direct lane faster than a fuel surcharge you agreed to without checking the math against your own truck.
On a recent episode of The Long Haul, Adam Wingfield spent most of his time on finding local shippers. Then he slowed down and made a point a lot of carriers skip right past. Home-court advantage doesn’t help you if you price the freight wrong, and not all direct freight is good freight. A direct relationship you lose money on is just a slower way to go out of business. This lesson covers the piece of pricing that hurts small carriers most often, the fuel surcharge, plus the other terms that need to be on paper before you roll.
Know Your Breakeven First
You can’t price fuel until you know your number. Your cost per mile is your total operating cost divided by your total miles, and it has to include fuel at today’s price, not what you paid last spring. The American Transportation Research Institute put the industry average at $2.336 a mile in 2025, a record. In that same study, fuel ran about 48 cents a mile. Diesel hasn’t stayed anywhere near those 2025 prices.
The EIA’s weekly national average was $6.127 a gallon for the week of Nov. 9, and it had been above $5 for 16 straight weeks. At 6.5 miles per gallon, $6.13 diesel works out to about 94 cents a mile in fuel alone, nearly double the 2025 average. If your cost per mile still assumes last year’s diesel, you’re quoting off a number that no longer exists. Run yours fresh with the cost per mile calculator before you quote anybody.
How a Fuel Surcharge Works
A fuel surcharge separates fuel from your line-haul rate so the rate doesn’t have to be renegotiated every time the pump moves. The common formula takes the current EIA diesel price, subtracts a base price both sides agree on, and divides by an assumed miles per gallon. The answer is your surcharge per mile.
Here’s how that plays out at today’s prices. With diesel at $6.13, a $1.25 base and a 6.5 mpg assumption, the math is $6.13 minus $1.25, which is $4.88, divided by 6.5. That’s about 75 cents a mile on top of your line-haul rate. When diesel falls, the surcharge falls. When it climbs, the surcharge climbs with it, and your line-haul margin stays protected.

Check the Three Numbers That Can Hurt You
Most carriers look at the surcharge and nod. The ones who stay in business check three things.
The base price. The base is the diesel price that’s assumed to already be baked into your line-haul rate. A higher base means a smaller surcharge. If a shipper hands you a table with a base well above what you assumed when you set your rate, you’re quietly eating fuel you thought was covered.
The mpg assumption. This is where small carriers get hurt the most. If the table assumes 6.5 miles per gallon and your truck really gets 6.0, the table pays you about 75 cents a mile when your truck burns about 81. That six-cent gap sounds small. Over 100,000 miles, it’s roughly $6,250 out of your pocket. Use your real fuel economy from your own fuel receipts, not a number somebody else picked.
The index. Tie the surcharge to the weekly EIA on-highway diesel price, and say in writing which week’s number applies to which loads. A surcharge that only gets updated monthly, or one tied to some price nobody can check, is an argument waiting to happen.

Put the Accessorials in Writing Too
Direct relationships usually fall apart over surprises, not rates. Spell out detention, layover, TONU and lumper fees before the first load. Say when detention starts, what it pays per hour and how it gets documented. If you’ve ever argued with a broker over a $75 detention charge, imagine having that argument with a customer you see every week. Get it agreed while everybody’s happy. For the full rate-setting process, use How to Price a Direct Lane From Your Cost Per Mile and How to Put a Shipper Deal in Writing.
Don’t Bet the Business on One Shipper
Once a local lane is running well, it’s tempting to give it every hour you have. Ask yourself one question first. What happens if my biggest customer stops calling tomorrow? If the honest answer is that you’re done, you’re not diversified. You’re dependent.
Aim for several local shippers. One or two dedicated lanes become your anchor, and the load board becomes your overflow insurance, not your foundation. Keep the relationships you win alive, too. Check in on a schedule, ask what’s working and what isn’t, and ask for referrals. Reliability is what earns you the right to ask for the next lane. As Adam put it on the show, direct freight doesn’t protect you from bad math. It just gives you better customers to do the math on.
Questions Carriers Ask
What if the shipper doesn’t want to pay a fuel surcharge? Then build fuel into an all-in rate, but price it at today’s diesel and agree on a date to review it. Going all-in without a review clause means you carry all the fuel risk alone. Most shippers who’ve bought freight for any length of time already expect a surcharge, so ask before you assume they’ll say no.
Should I use the shipper’s surcharge table or bring my own? Either works if you check it. Many shippers already have a table they use with every carrier. Before you sign, run their base price and mpg against your own numbers. If their table loses you money, show them your math and propose an adjustment. Numbers on paper make that conversation a lot easier.
Diesel just dropped. Does that mean I should lower my rate? No. That’s the whole point of a surcharge. When diesel falls, the surcharge drops automatically and your line-haul rate stays put. If you’ve been quoting all-in rates, that’s exactly why you want a surcharge on your next deal.
How often should I recheck my cost per mile? At least every quarter, and any time diesel, insurance or a truck payment changes in a big way. Your costs move whether you look at them or not.
This Week’s Assignment
Pull your fuel receipts and mileage for the last 90 days and figure out your real miles per gallon. Then run the surcharge formula three ways using this week’s EIA diesel price, at a $1.25 base, a $1.50 base and a $2.00 base, using your real mpg. Write down how much each one pays per mile. Now you’ll know in ten seconds whether a shipper’s table works for you or against you.
Learn this next
If you haven’t built your list yet, start with How to Find Shippers Near You With Google Maps and How to Read a Shipper’s Yard Before You Walk In. After the deal is signed, read How to Keep a Shipper After the First Load so the lane keeps paying.
Bottom Line
Winning local freight is half the job. Keeping it profitable is the other half, and it starts with a fuel surcharge you’ve checked against your own truck, accessorials spelled out before the first load and enough customers that no single one can sink you. Do the math before you sign, not after.
Watch the full episode on The Long Haul.

Innovative Logistics Group

